November 19, 2026
Is Winter a Bad Time to Rent Out Your House? How to Lease in the Off-Season
Key Takeaways
- Fewer people move between Thanksgiving and New Year's, so homes take longer to lease in late fall and winter, but good residents still move.
- Price at the market, or slightly under. Winter is the wrong time to push the rent above your comps.
- Show a warm, well-lit home. With early sunsets, most showings happen after dark.
- Set winter leases to end in spring or summer (often 15 to 18 months) so the next turnover lands in peak season.
- Keep the same screening standards year-round. A slow season is no reason to change your criteria.
It's November. The holidays are coming, it's getting cold, and you have a house coming open for rent. Is it a bad time? Not necessarily bad, but definitely different from spring. Our CEO, Brian Mullins, learned that the hard way: the first rental he ever bought was ready to lease in early October, and he wasn't prepared for the off-season. Here's what he wishes he'd known, from his recent video.
Why Winter Is Different
Most people simply aren't looking to move between Thanksgiving and the new year, whether they rent or buy. They're focused on the holidays. Moves also cluster around the break between school years, so demand picks up in March and April and peaks in summer.
That means fewer people looking at your listing, longer days on market, and less room on price. It doesn't mean nobody moves: people still relocate for jobs and other firm reasons in winter, and those moves often come with a clear timeline.
1. Price It Right, Not High
This is where Brian went wrong on his first rental. His comps said one number, and he figured he could push a little higher. He couldn't. Rents generally run higher in spring and summer and cool off in fall and winter, so pricing above your comps in November usually just adds weeks of vacancy.
Price at the market, or even slightly under it. One vacant month costs more than a modest discount, especially when it's a winter month with fewer people looking. Our guide to pricing a rental walks through pulling current comps.
2. Make the Home Easy to Say Yes To
This matters all year, but winter raises the stakes:
- Keep the heat on. It doesn't need to be 75 degrees, just warm enough that nobody is shivering during a showing. A cold house leaves a bad first impression, and in a hard freeze, an unheated vacant home risks burst pipes.
- Light it up. After daylight saving time ends, it's dark by 5:30 or 6:00, which is exactly when most people can come see a house after work. Make sure every bulb works, turn on the porch and exterior lights, and make the switches easy to find. In summer, natural light hides a dead bulb; in winter it doesn't.
- Keep it clean and inviting. A home that feels warm and cared for leases faster in any season. Our rent-ready guide covers what to fix before listing.
3. Set the Lease Term to End in Peak Season
We don't sign 12-month leases in fall and winter, because that just sets up another off-season vacancy a year later. Instead, we usually offer a longer first term, often around 15 to 18 months depending on the month, so the lease ends in spring or summer.
It's a fair deal for the resident, too. When they eventually move, whether to another rental or a home of their own, they'll have far more options to choose from in spring and summer.
4. Don't Lower Your Standards
A slow season can tempt owners to accept an applicant they'd normally decline. Don't. Apply the same written screening criteria in December that you use in June. Changing your standards for some applicants creates fair housing risk, and a resident who stops paying after a month or two leaves you worse off than a vacant house. Our tenant screening guide covers the criteria we use.
Bottom Line
Winter leasing is slower, not hopeless. Price at the market, show a warm and well-lit home, set the lease to end in peak season, and keep your standards the same. Good residents move in winter too; there are just fewer of them.
Have a home coming open this winter? Get a free rental analysis to see where its rent should be today.
Frequently Asked Questions
Is winter a bad time to rent out a house?
It's slower, not bad. Fewer people move between Thanksgiving and New Year's, so homes usually take longer to lease. Pricing at the market and showing a warm, well-lit home helps it lease anyway.
Should I lower my rent in the winter?
Don't price above your comps in winter. Pricing at the market, or slightly under if competing homes are sitting, usually costs less than an extra month of vacancy.
How long should a lease be if it starts in winter?
Long enough to end in spring or summer. We often use a first term of about 15 to 18 months for fall and winter move-ins so the next turnover falls in peak leasing season.
Watch: Is Winter a Bad Time to Rent Out Your House?

Is Winter a Bad Time to Rent Out Your House?
It's November, the holidays are coming, and you've got a house coming up for rent. Is that a bad time? Not necessarily, but winter is different. Property manager Brian Mullins of 1907 Property Management covers why…